I loved Conor McPherson’s The Weir when I saw it at the Donmar Warehouse a few years ago, so I was keen to see his earlier play Shining City when it was revived at the Theatre Royal Stratford East. As with The Weir, Shining City uses the medium of a ghost story to explore themes of grief and loss.
The play centres around a middle-aged man, John, who visits therapist Ian after the death of his wife – constantly seeing her in the house they shared, he has retreated to a local B&B. At first we feel sympathy for John, who is clearly struggling to cope, but as we learn more about him, other feelings are added to the mix: John is something of an unpleasant character, self-obsessed, arrogant and unfeeling towards his life while she was still alive. And yet, it is a triumph of McPherson’s play, and Brendan Coyle’s spellbinding performance, that our sympathy is not completely diminished. He portrays this complex character as someone whose guilt, both acknowledged and unacknowledged, may have prompted the apparitions with which he is haunted. Coyle has several long speeches, and even his massive monologue in the middle of the play does not slow things down or diminish the tension; instead, it is thoroughly compelling.
As time passes, we see that therapist Ian (an excellent Rory Keenan) has his own issues to work through: a past in the priesthood, a turbulent relationship and a child, a pursuit of unexplored sexuality. I thought these scenes were too slight to fully explore the character, and would have liked them to be either omitted altogether – with a full focus on John – or fleshed out more. Having said that, Michelle Fox and Curtis-Lee Ashqar give strong performances as Ian’s on-off fiance and the rent boy he picks up. The overarching theme of the play seemed to me to be flawed masculinity and male guilt, and the fact that neither of the main male characters openly acknowledges this makes its impact all the stronger.
The play’s shock twist didn’t make as much impact on me as I would have liked – it seemed to have been handled in a bit of a rush – but overall this was a powerful and impactful play.